Forum issues
Original Post
Just wondering if others think that the problems that people are having with the forum are due to the structure of it? You can batter away at the problem in a labour intensive way (if there even is a problem perceived) through heavy moderation which is kind of silly and has been unnecessary for the most part - or create a structure that actually makes it easier to do the right thing - ie. go off topic and whatnot in the right place.
Lots of techie people are on here that could probably assist with a transition to something else. Norman can even set up the search tool.
Like everyone else, I think it's wonderful that Mark is retired and doing stuff he is drawn to do. But isn't this a case sort of like the E-myth, where you have to step aside and think about working on your system rather than in the system?
Lots of techie people are on here that could probably assist with a transition to something else. Norman can even set up the search tool.
Like everyone else, I think it's wonderful that Mark is retired and doing stuff he is drawn to do. But isn't this a case sort of like the E-myth, where you have to step aside and think about working on your system rather than in the system?
Reply by Rainer
Jacqueline,
is there really any problem? Some people post some silly nonsense sometimes, including myself. So what? Laugh about it or ignore it.
If Mark wants to delete any posting, he will surely do.
is there really any problem? Some people post some silly nonsense sometimes, including myself. So what? Laugh about it or ignore it.
If Mark wants to delete any posting, he will surely do.
Reply by Jacqueline
I totally agree - for myself Rainer. And it provides some levity on a subject that we seem to get pretty uptight over at times.
But it seems to bother some other people a lot. How many other people does it bother that just go away without saying anything about it?
But it seems to bother some other people a lot. How many other people does it bother that just go away without saying anything about it?
Reply by vegheadjones
I am certainly guilty of (attempting if not succeeding) in adding levity, but I think you have a good point Jacqueline. There are times when I am interested in a topic, get excited that there are new posts there (thanks to the highlighting provided by Andreas' extension), open it up only to be disappointed by the off-topic digression.
And other times I am in a off-topic mood myself and enjoy reading them.
It would be great if there was a way to separate the wheat from the chaff, so to speak, without sacrificing the chaff.
And other times I am in a off-topic mood myself and enjoy reading them.
It would be great if there was a way to separate the wheat from the chaff, so to speak, without sacrificing the chaff.
Reply by TK
I would support a "time management" section and an "off-topic" section, but it's up to Mark whether he wants to make the split I suppose. Not sure how much technical upkeep there is to doing that.
Reply by Norman U.
I should be the mod with all posts OKed by me before allowing them on the forum.
Or people could just use the scroll wheel or space bar to skip what they don't to read.
If you want to kill anything interesting here other than what size notebook do you use for AF3, making a separate off-topic forum is the sensible solution. Conservations are organic and evolve.
Or when a topic starts to really wander you can just start a new "off-topic" thread and continue the discussion there. Three posts about an Hollywood director from Austria is hardly a hijack.
Really, I have yet to see any thread go far off-topic. Heck, its rare to see any thread has more than a few dozen posts.
I fail to see the big deal.
Or people could just use the scroll wheel or space bar to skip what they don't to read.
If you want to kill anything interesting here other than what size notebook do you use for AF3, making a separate off-topic forum is the sensible solution. Conservations are organic and evolve.
Or when a topic starts to really wander you can just start a new "off-topic" thread and continue the discussion there. Three posts about an Hollywood director from Austria is hardly a hijack.
Really, I have yet to see any thread go far off-topic. Heck, its rare to see any thread has more than a few dozen posts.
I fail to see the big deal.
Reply by Jacqueline
>>Or when a topic starts to really wander you can just start a new "off-topic" thread and continue the discussion there.<<
Ya mean like this?
veghead, you've got a gift, you've made me spit out my coffee more than once.
I don't know for sure - but it seems to be a recent phenomenon. Not sure why that is. Likely that the issue - if there is one - will just resolve itself and go back to how it was before.
One of the good things about threads from months ago was that you knew that if a thread was on goals, had 60+ posts on it, it was probably Mike and co. expounding on anything and everything. It kept things kind of tidy in a roundabout way.
Ya mean like this?
veghead, you've got a gift, you've made me spit out my coffee more than once.
I don't know for sure - but it seems to be a recent phenomenon. Not sure why that is. Likely that the issue - if there is one - will just resolve itself and go back to how it was before.
One of the good things about threads from months ago was that you knew that if a thread was on goals, had 60+ posts on it, it was probably Mike and co. expounding on anything and everything. It kept things kind of tidy in a roundabout way.
Reply by vegheadjones
>>veghead, you've got a gift, you've made me spit out my coffee more than once.
Hope nothing important got drenched! And I hope that my causing this is not necessarily a bad thing...
Hope nothing important got drenched! And I hope that my causing this is not necessarily a bad thing...
Reply by TK
lol, Norman, I enjoy your posts, off topic or not
Reply by Rainer
Some people seem to be annoyed with the court jester.
Reply by Norman U.
Only the fool was suffered to speak truth to the King.
Reply by Rainer
Agreed, but can't the fool show any compassion for himself, or at least for the king?
Reply by Rainer
What would happen, if the fool gave up suffering?
Would the king be lost?
Would the king be lost?
Reply by Norma L.
>>Only the fool was suffered to speak truth to the King. <<
Are you calling me a fool oh King?
Are you calling me a fool oh King?
Reply by Norma LOL
Oh, Norma L
Your humor is deliciously wicked!
Your humor is deliciously wicked!
Reply by Greg T
What an absolute joke this has all become, the best thing Mark can do is pull the whole forum - it's all been totally ruined - congratulations everyone.
Reply by Rainer
This isn't a joke, nor is it funny, Greg, but I'm trying to find out why Norman is playing the court jester at this forum.
Reply by Greg T
I never said it was funny Rainer, far from it in fact, I used to find this forum really helpful but now, with Norman's help, it's all been destroyed.
Reply by Bryant 1963
Long time lurker!
The most frequent posters on this forum, also happen to be the most heavily invested in Mark's system. Yet, the frequency with which they post (off topic and otherwise), can only mean two things:
a) They are rapidly cycling through their Autofocus, DIT, or DWM lists and taking action on: "post on Mark's forum"
b) A major goal is to make online friends, have online discussions, etc. Most probably they aren't using any productivity system to this.
Funny that Mark is not taking part. He's using his systems to take action on major life goals.
I noticed the same thing happening on davidco.com. I wonder why frequent posters aren't spending more time with real people - friends, family & colleagues? The lesson seems to be that productivity systems don't cure loneliness or dissatisfaction with hobbies, relationships and/or career.
The most frequent posters on this forum, also happen to be the most heavily invested in Mark's system. Yet, the frequency with which they post (off topic and otherwise), can only mean two things:
a) They are rapidly cycling through their Autofocus, DIT, or DWM lists and taking action on: "post on Mark's forum"
b) A major goal is to make online friends, have online discussions, etc. Most probably they aren't using any productivity system to this.
Funny that Mark is not taking part. He's using his systems to take action on major life goals.
I noticed the same thing happening on davidco.com. I wonder why frequent posters aren't spending more time with real people - friends, family & colleagues? The lesson seems to be that productivity systems don't cure loneliness or dissatisfaction with hobbies, relationships and/or career.
Reply by Jacqueline
Hi Greg,
I don't think that's the case - or I hope not. But it's concerns like yours that I do think really should be addressed. I do hope that the off-topic-ness can be somewhat compartmentalized. I just think the answer isn't to complain about it, but to look for some kind of solutions rather than throw the baby out with the bathwater, KWIM?
I don't think that's the case - or I hope not. But it's concerns like yours that I do think really should be addressed. I do hope that the off-topic-ness can be somewhat compartmentalized. I just think the answer isn't to complain about it, but to look for some kind of solutions rather than throw the baby out with the bathwater, KWIM?
Reply by Greg T
But surely the solution is to treat this forum as what it should be, for discussing time management issues.
Unfortunately this seems now to be just a place for having random, completely unrelated conversations akin to the sort a teenager has in a chatroom.
Unfortunately this seems now to be just a place for having random, completely unrelated conversations akin to the sort a teenager has in a chatroom.
Reply by Rainer
Bryant wrote:
<>
Definitely true! There is more to life than being productive.
<
Definitely true! There is more to life than being productive.
Reply by Rainer
Greg wrote:
"But surely the solution is to treat this forum as what it should be, for discussing time management issues."
Okay, but how can this be done without constant moderation?
"But surely the solution is to treat this forum as what it should be, for discussing time management issues."
Okay, but how can this be done without constant moderation?
Reply by Jacqueline
Bryant, isn't part of it that you take people (who are basically tribal by nature), stick them in little boxes called cubicles or offices, tell them not to interact with their coworkers or they aren't being 'efficient', block sites where they can interact with their friends - then they'll look for ways to interact with their 'tribe' (in this case people who are interested in TM).
I don't think it was an issue before because there's been a bit of mean-spiritedness in the mix lately that wasn't there before and that brings out people's anger.
I don't think it was an issue before because there's been a bit of mean-spiritedness in the mix lately that wasn't there before and that brings out people's anger.
Reply by Norman U.
Ranier:
Greg wrote:
"But surely the solution is to treat this forum as what it should be, for discussing time management issues."
Okay, but how can this be done without constant moderation?"
Already gave the answer: create content and new threads about whatever you want.
Note almost nothing was posted to the thread I made about AF. Why? Not much to say. Mark created a brilliant system. Easy and effective. What's left?
What time interval works the best with pomodoro technique?
The solution to a complaint about something you can fix is to stop complaining and start fixing.
Post interesting and engaging posts about your trouble with time management.
Problem is that for myself or most anyone else, Mark did a pretty good job answering most of the questions to be asked.
Greg wrote:
"But surely the solution is to treat this forum as what it should be, for discussing time management issues."
Okay, but how can this be done without constant moderation?"
Already gave the answer: create content and new threads about whatever you want.
Note almost nothing was posted to the thread I made about AF. Why? Not much to say. Mark created a brilliant system. Easy and effective. What's left?
What time interval works the best with pomodoro technique?
The solution to a complaint about something you can fix is to stop complaining and start fixing.
Post interesting and engaging posts about your trouble with time management.
Problem is that for myself or most anyone else, Mark did a pretty good job answering most of the questions to be asked.
Reply by Standing Against List 'Marms
When forums become mature, they can be ruined not by the banter of the "old hands" so much as the tantrums of those who come out of the woodwork only to complain that things are not so much to their liking. Then those who have the most valuable input, wander off as the place becomes unfriendly to them. Like it or not, that is the way society works. If you want value, you have to be willing to give value in return. Norman likes to muse about this and that and pull everyone's leg. If you try to stuff him into a box, he'll go somewhere else to play then you'll lose his input.
If you were to waste time building a matrix of the number of posts "of value" from people who were "problems" (as determined by list 'marms) vs the posts of value from those 'marms themselves, I think you'd see my point dramatically.
In any case, light the tourches, storm the castle, run from the hot lead, when it is all over and done with, this will be a friendly place where we come to meet friends and help each other ... or a very quiet place where people ask questions and get only silence in response. You've all seen THOSE places.
In short, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. If you THINK it's broke, rethink it.
If you were to waste time building a matrix of the number of posts "of value" from people who were "problems" (as determined by list 'marms) vs the posts of value from those 'marms themselves, I think you'd see my point dramatically.
In any case, light the tourches, storm the castle, run from the hot lead, when it is all over and done with, this will be a friendly place where we come to meet friends and help each other ... or a very quiet place where people ask questions and get only silence in response. You've all seen THOSE places.
In short, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. If you THINK it's broke, rethink it.
Reply by Jacqueline
Interesting article on Richard Dawkins' attempted moderation of his site:
http://www.newenglishreview.org/custpage.cfm/frm/58706/sec_id/58706
http://www.newenglishreview.org/custpage.cfm/frm/58706/sec_id/58706
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
That is quite an interesting article. I'm thinking of some recent public reactions to the recent vote in the U.S. on health care reform. It seems as if it could be easily substituted.
I'm going to read a bit more by the writer, but I did find him a bit ... forced, shall I say? But mostly logical.
Thanks for the pointer ... excellent, as usual ;-)
That is quite an interesting article. I'm thinking of some recent public reactions to the recent vote in the U.S. on health care reform. It seems as if it could be easily substituted.
I'm going to read a bit more by the writer, but I did find him a bit ... forced, shall I say? But mostly logical.
Thanks for the pointer ... excellent, as usual ;-)
Reply by Norman U.
Holy cripes Standing, where did you suddenly come from? This is one of the most sensible and well-written posts I've seen here.
Reply by Will
I stand with Standing.
This has always been a friendly and relaxed conversation, not a database. Mark has stated his view on this very clearly.
We are happy to answer questions repeatedly. A handful of people seem unhappy with this. They are very welcome to leave or to stay and chat. If anyone feels that a question has not been answered, they only have to say so.
This has always been a friendly and relaxed conversation, not a database. Mark has stated his view on this very clearly.
We are happy to answer questions repeatedly. A handful of people seem unhappy with this. They are very welcome to leave or to stay and chat. If anyone feels that a question has not been answered, they only have to say so.
Reply by Steve
Is it possible that we've run out of things to talk about -- hence this harmless, low-grade bickering like people stuck in a train station?
Reply by Jacqueline
Excellent points Anti-Marm and Will !!
Forums are not a database and for many things, if you really wanted clear to-the-point answers to TM questions, go to Mark's past articles on his blog - they're really very excellent.
The other forum I go on - http://www.early-retirement.org/forums/
goes off topic ALL the time after a question has been answered, and sometimes before. Other E-R forums are much more ON-TOPIC (but boring and not as helpful). Some have died out completely over the 6+ years I've lurked on there. They're absolutely hilarious on E-R.org and cuz they're retired I guess, some of them are super active on the forum. They're also very helpful because despite many being retired, they've BTDT and are willing to give back. All they ask in return is a place for them to congregate and give each other a hard time.
At some point in any forum, a community of sorts gets built up and people just aren't that one dimensional. When you're talking about management of time, you're talking about management of your life. That's a pretty big topic (or irrelevant depending on your perspective - nihilistic or anti-nihilistic.)
As far as I know, the only rule Mark has is to keep it civil.
Oh, and I'm still waiting for the answer to Rainer's questions. Norman, any insights?
Forums are not a database and for many things, if you really wanted clear to-the-point answers to TM questions, go to Mark's past articles on his blog - they're really very excellent.
The other forum I go on - http://www.early-retirement.org/forums/
goes off topic ALL the time after a question has been answered, and sometimes before. Other E-R forums are much more ON-TOPIC (but boring and not as helpful). Some have died out completely over the 6+ years I've lurked on there. They're absolutely hilarious on E-R.org and cuz they're retired I guess, some of them are super active on the forum. They're also very helpful because despite many being retired, they've BTDT and are willing to give back. All they ask in return is a place for them to congregate and give each other a hard time.
At some point in any forum, a community of sorts gets built up and people just aren't that one dimensional. When you're talking about management of time, you're talking about management of your life. That's a pretty big topic (or irrelevant depending on your perspective - nihilistic or anti-nihilistic.)
As far as I know, the only rule Mark has is to keep it civil.
Oh, and I'm still waiting for the answer to Rainer's questions. Norman, any insights?
Reply by Norman U.
His questions are ironic and rhetorical, thus mean and low and answering them would bring me down to his level.
If people don't stop mocking me I will this forum forever.
Is that how you do it?
Seriously, the adults are turning up in this thread at its end after the children have gone to sleep. Standing and the rest of you have said pretty much all there is say here that I haven't on the topic.
If people don't stop mocking me I will this forum forever.
Is that how you do it?
Seriously, the adults are turning up in this thread at its end after the children have gone to sleep. Standing and the rest of you have said pretty much all there is say here that I haven't on the topic.
Reply by Norman U.
Mike:
"I'm going to read a bit more by the writer, but I did find him a bit ... forced, shall I say?"
Yeah he sounds like a real party, but with a name like "Theodore Dalrymple" did ever have a chance?
Never thought I would be able to read something more dry, irrelevant, or arrogant than some of Dawkins' prose, thanks to Teddy, now I have. (I did only make through the first 8 and half words to be fair.)
"I'm going to read a bit more by the writer, but I did find him a bit ... forced, shall I say?"
Yeah he sounds like a real party, but with a name like "Theodore Dalrymple" did ever have a chance?
Never thought I would be able to read something more dry, irrelevant, or arrogant than some of Dawkins' prose, thanks to Teddy, now I have. (I did only make through the first 8 and half words to be fair.)
Reply by Jacqueline
Norman, I'm just honoured you clicked on the article at all. *blush*
I will summarize it for you in 8 words: People can be really mean on the internet.
If people don't stop mocking you, you will _______ this forum forever. What's the missing verb? Haunt, torture, love??
I will summarize it for you in 8 words: People can be really mean on the internet.
If people don't stop mocking you, you will _______ this forum forever. What's the missing verb? Haunt, torture, love??
Reply by Norman U.
Jacqueline:
"What's the missing verb? Haunt, torture, love??"
I've never known one without the other two.
"What's the missing verb? Haunt, torture, love??"
I've never known one without the other two.
Reply by Mike
Whoa, dude!
Reply by Norman U.
Your response might explain the stack of restraining orders on my desk.
Reply by Mike
ROTFLMAO ;-) Norman, you are a true diamond in the rough!
Reply by Mel
Speaking of restraining orders...Norman, you remind me of a guy I dated just once. He told me he couldn't understand why women were afraid of him. He said, "Sure, I've smashed some furniture and broken down a few doors, but I've never hit anyone." You weren't ever a factory worker in the Midwest whose stated hobby was driving really fast on the shoulders of the road, were you????? LOL
Reply by Seraphim
AYBABTU
Sorry, it just seemed appropriate for some reason. :-)
Sorry, it just seemed appropriate for some reason. :-)
Reply by Alison R
I may be in the minority here, but my thoughts are:
1. I come here for time management advice - that's all really.
2. I find some of the obscure off topic discussions really off putting - they seem to appear on every thread now so it's hard to find the useful stuff from the banal.
3. I do belong to another forum - have been a member since 2005 - and it has never been nasty or bickering, just supportive and helpful - so it is possible. I also belong to other forums that I have been using for a shorter period of time and they are respectful of others also.
4. Most other forums I belong to respect others posts and don't go off topic - there is an off topic area reserved for this type of 'chat'
5. Why not just post topics that are off topic with a heading that starts OT - then everyone knows what they are and can read or ignore as they prefer?
6. I believe that in any forum we have to respect each other and each others views. There is nothing wrong with having a bit of fun or a bit of a ramble into other areas, but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone?
1. I come here for time management advice - that's all really.
2. I find some of the obscure off topic discussions really off putting - they seem to appear on every thread now so it's hard to find the useful stuff from the banal.
3. I do belong to another forum - have been a member since 2005 - and it has never been nasty or bickering, just supportive and helpful - so it is possible. I also belong to other forums that I have been using for a shorter period of time and they are respectful of others also.
4. Most other forums I belong to respect others posts and don't go off topic - there is an off topic area reserved for this type of 'chat'
5. Why not just post topics that are off topic with a heading that starts OT - then everyone knows what they are and can read or ignore as they prefer?
6. I believe that in any forum we have to respect each other and each others views. There is nothing wrong with having a bit of fun or a bit of a ramble into other areas, but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone?
Reply by clara
Alison, my post a few days back ...
"A certain amount of off-topic chat is unavoidable in most forums,
however one solution is to have an "Anything and Everything" thread where people can go and discuss - well, anything and everything, thereby leaving the "Please help" threads somewhat more chat-free than they are now. Mark of course should have the last word, but I think that would be acceptable to all parties here."
March 25, 2010 at 9:57 | clara
It's knowing where to draw the line between a bit of friendly chat and a discussion that is light years away from the original topic.
"A certain amount of off-topic chat is unavoidable in most forums,
however one solution is to have an "Anything and Everything" thread where people can go and discuss - well, anything and everything, thereby leaving the "Please help" threads somewhat more chat-free than they are now. Mark of course should have the last word, but I think that would be acceptable to all parties here."
March 25, 2010 at 9:57 | clara
It's knowing where to draw the line between a bit of friendly chat and a discussion that is light years away from the original topic.
Reply by Norman U.
Alison:
"but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone?"
A bit presumptive, speaking for everyone?
I still for the life of me cannot understand why the space bar and scroll wheel are such hard things to use.
A few posts that go away from a topic are not hard to navigate. If someone wants to take a topic and go form an explicit thread for it fine.
This all assumes everyone agrees about what is on and off topic.
And frankly the subject matter of the topics ain't topology. If I had my way, people would not use so many words to say to so little about how to make a list of things they might do. I complain once in a while, mostly in jest, but I just skip those windy posts.
"but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone?"
A bit presumptive, speaking for everyone?
I still for the life of me cannot understand why the space bar and scroll wheel are such hard things to use.
A few posts that go away from a topic are not hard to navigate. If someone wants to take a topic and go form an explicit thread for it fine.
This all assumes everyone agrees about what is on and off topic.
And frankly the subject matter of the topics ain't topology. If I had my way, people would not use so many words to say to so little about how to make a list of things they might do. I complain once in a while, mostly in jest, but I just skip those windy posts.
Reply by Norman U.
Clara:
"however one solution is to have an "Anything and Everything" thread where people can go and discuss - well, anything and everything, thereby leaving the "Please help" threads somewhat more chat-free than they are now."
Conversation evolves organically. Yours is a workable solution, if you want every thread to be tedious and dry including your "Anything and Everything" thread. You will also have to have a mod who shares your sense and sensibility. Some folks like that. Some don't. Thankfully the world is rarely one extreme or another so most folks are capable of getting along well enough without moderation since the world tends to moderate itself.
So.
Clara, please suggest a topic so complex and difficult to follow that has appeared here recently that a few "off-topic" posts made it impossible or difficult to follow. Some of the early DWM threads maybe, but since those were by nature interesting of themselves to those participating in them, almost no "off-topic" content appeared.
Again: The Lesser Banishing Ritual of Content You Do Not Like
1.) Offer more content yourself.
2.) Make said content more interesting and useful than what is currently being offered.
3.) Repeat.
"however one solution is to have an "Anything and Everything" thread where people can go and discuss - well, anything and everything, thereby leaving the "Please help" threads somewhat more chat-free than they are now."
Conversation evolves organically. Yours is a workable solution, if you want every thread to be tedious and dry including your "Anything and Everything" thread. You will also have to have a mod who shares your sense and sensibility. Some folks like that. Some don't. Thankfully the world is rarely one extreme or another so most folks are capable of getting along well enough without moderation since the world tends to moderate itself.
So.
Clara, please suggest a topic so complex and difficult to follow that has appeared here recently that a few "off-topic" posts made it impossible or difficult to follow. Some of the early DWM threads maybe, but since those were by nature interesting of themselves to those participating in them, almost no "off-topic" content appeared.
Again: The Lesser Banishing Ritual of Content You Do Not Like
1.) Offer more content yourself.
2.) Make said content more interesting and useful than what is currently being offered.
3.) Repeat.
Reply by Alison R
Reply by Norman U.
Me: <>
Alison: So why are you here if it's so easy and time management is no problem for you?
Please, explain to me how you jump to your conclusion based on what I wrote? (That was rhetorical) If you are interested in what I think of AF just read the discussion Alan and I are having.
Alison: So why are you here if it's so easy and time management is no problem for you?
Please, explain to me how you jump to your conclusion based on what I wrote? (That was rhetorical) If you are interested in what I think of AF just read the discussion Alan and I are having.
Reply by Norman U.
As to why I am here?
First to figure out how to use AF.
Then to get some infos from folks who post decent content.
Then try to do latter from time to time.
Then bring some levity along the way (the fact I have to explain pains).
Then noticed that some people had interesting stuff to say about things related to AF IMHO: Religion, personal experiences, psychology, etc. I agree with some of it and disagree as well. I figure most are adults can handle reading words on a screen without taking too much insult, even if they are not what they agree with. Some obviously can't. Been around long enough to see the formula repeated many times.
Right now? I've been working on a writing project for hours and hours. And this is like a little bit of caffeine to keep the writing momentum going, or so AF suggests.
First to figure out how to use AF.
Then to get some infos from folks who post decent content.
Then try to do latter from time to time.
Then bring some levity along the way (the fact I have to explain pains).
Then noticed that some people had interesting stuff to say about things related to AF IMHO: Religion, personal experiences, psychology, etc. I agree with some of it and disagree as well. I figure most are adults can handle reading words on a screen without taking too much insult, even if they are not what they agree with. Some obviously can't. Been around long enough to see the formula repeated many times.
Right now? I've been working on a writing project for hours and hours. And this is like a little bit of caffeine to keep the writing momentum going, or so AF suggests.
Reply by Mike
Allison,
I think it has been said in several ways and several times already but I'll take your post point by point to be sure it is covered ;-)
>>> 1. I come here for time management advice - that's all really. <<<
That is your reason to be here. Others have different reasons. Those of us who have been here a while and "know all there is to know" ;-) are here mostly for community. I have been here for over a year now so I've been through AF1->4 and DWM. By now I kind of get what Mark is proposing.
>>> 2. I find some of the obscure off topic discussions really off putting - they seem to appear on every thread now so it's hard to find the useful stuff from the banal. <<<
As much as you don't get why we like to talk amongst ourselves, I don't get why you find it so off putting. So what if they appear on every thread. Pass on by. Elsewhere you say you have a hard time with the space bar because you have to read. I just can't wrap my mind around that. I read all kinds of nonsense and am none the worse for wear ... for wear ... for wear ;-)
>>> 3. I do belong to another forum - have been a member since 2005 - and it has never been nasty or bickering, just supportive and helpful - so it is possible. I also belong to other forums that I have been using for a shorter period of time and they are respectful of others also. <<<
As is this one. The only disrespect I've seen lately comes from those who want Norman to go away because they don't like what he has to say. It is not those who are chattering who are not respectful. Is there much disrespectful about the posts by Mel, Jacqueline, Seraphim? I don't think so.
>>> 4. Most other forums I belong to respect others posts and don't go off topic - there is an off topic area reserved for this type of 'chat' <<<
Two things here:
1) Posting off topic is not disrespect ... it is simply posting information that is not on topic. "Respect", in this case, is a characterization and yours differs from mine.
B) People don't simply answer a post with something totally out of left field. The "conversation" (and that is exactly what it is, even if it looks like a series of disconnected posts) "drifts". One idea least to another. Moreover, in most cases the question has been answered directly, by serveral posters in several ways with several (often differing) points of view ... BEFORE it drifts off topic. In fact, the drifting is often because the discussion becomes about the differences of points of view. There is most often no RIGHT answer. There is my answer and Mel's answer and the the wrong answer ... Norman's ;-) ;-)
3) As mentioned elsewhere, how do you know what the topic of your post is before you write it? I don't. I may start on place and wind up at another.
iv) Seriously, do you think that it even makes sense to read a post and then go someplace else to answer it just because your answer, while relevant, does not actually answer a question posed. That would be highly distracting. Every other post in that area would start with: "Joe asked ... and that got me thinking about the phases of the moon so ..." Come on now ;-) Does anyone do that IRL? If you listen analytically to any conversation, it drifts all over the place. Do you say: "Oh, wait, before we change he subject, are we finished with this one?" You'd have few friends! ;-) Yeah, other places have "off topic" areas but that does not stop things going off topic in answer to posts on specific topics. It is just human nature.
5) This is not a "forum" in structure. It is just a list of topics which are not allowed to exceed 100 posts or so. After that, Mark closes the topic. So there can BE no "off topic" thread. And if there were, people would complain that your off topic comment was off topic from the last off topic comment. OY!
>>> 5. Why not just post topics that are off topic with a heading that starts OT - then everyone knows what they are and can read or ignore as they prefer? <<<
What is "on topic" and what "off topic"? To one person AF is now off topic because Mark has introduced DWM. To another AF is on topic because the topic is Mark's Time Management systems. To another Covey is on topic because the topic is really Time Management systems in general. To others goals and values are on topic because in order to be effective in doing anything you need those, or so goes one school of thought. We've had discussions on planning, intuition, and what kinds of book to write in or software program to use. What the HELL is really ON topic? ;-)
>>> 6. I believe that in any forum we have to respect each other and each others views. There is nothing wrong with having a bit of fun or a bit of a ramble into other areas, but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone? <<<
Amen to the idea of respect. But I hope I have demonstrated the futility of even deciding what is relevant to whom. If Mark had more of a dictatorial bent, he would lay down a law. That is just not Mark, however so we have a lot of latitude ... and it has worked for the year and a quarter or so I've been here ... and other have been here longer and seem to be thriving.
I think it has been said in several ways and several times already but I'll take your post point by point to be sure it is covered ;-)
>>> 1. I come here for time management advice - that's all really. <<<
That is your reason to be here. Others have different reasons. Those of us who have been here a while and "know all there is to know" ;-) are here mostly for community. I have been here for over a year now so I've been through AF1->4 and DWM. By now I kind of get what Mark is proposing.
>>> 2. I find some of the obscure off topic discussions really off putting - they seem to appear on every thread now so it's hard to find the useful stuff from the banal. <<<
As much as you don't get why we like to talk amongst ourselves, I don't get why you find it so off putting. So what if they appear on every thread. Pass on by. Elsewhere you say you have a hard time with the space bar because you have to read. I just can't wrap my mind around that. I read all kinds of nonsense and am none the worse for wear ... for wear ... for wear ;-)
>>> 3. I do belong to another forum - have been a member since 2005 - and it has never been nasty or bickering, just supportive and helpful - so it is possible. I also belong to other forums that I have been using for a shorter period of time and they are respectful of others also. <<<
As is this one. The only disrespect I've seen lately comes from those who want Norman to go away because they don't like what he has to say. It is not those who are chattering who are not respectful. Is there much disrespectful about the posts by Mel, Jacqueline, Seraphim? I don't think so.
>>> 4. Most other forums I belong to respect others posts and don't go off topic - there is an off topic area reserved for this type of 'chat' <<<
Two things here:
1) Posting off topic is not disrespect ... it is simply posting information that is not on topic. "Respect", in this case, is a characterization and yours differs from mine.
B) People don't simply answer a post with something totally out of left field. The "conversation" (and that is exactly what it is, even if it looks like a series of disconnected posts) "drifts". One idea least to another. Moreover, in most cases the question has been answered directly, by serveral posters in several ways with several (often differing) points of view ... BEFORE it drifts off topic. In fact, the drifting is often because the discussion becomes about the differences of points of view. There is most often no RIGHT answer. There is my answer and Mel's answer and the the wrong answer ... Norman's ;-) ;-)
3) As mentioned elsewhere, how do you know what the topic of your post is before you write it? I don't. I may start on place and wind up at another.
iv) Seriously, do you think that it even makes sense to read a post and then go someplace else to answer it just because your answer, while relevant, does not actually answer a question posed. That would be highly distracting. Every other post in that area would start with: "Joe asked ... and that got me thinking about the phases of the moon so ..." Come on now ;-) Does anyone do that IRL? If you listen analytically to any conversation, it drifts all over the place. Do you say: "Oh, wait, before we change he subject, are we finished with this one?" You'd have few friends! ;-) Yeah, other places have "off topic" areas but that does not stop things going off topic in answer to posts on specific topics. It is just human nature.
5) This is not a "forum" in structure. It is just a list of topics which are not allowed to exceed 100 posts or so. After that, Mark closes the topic. So there can BE no "off topic" thread. And if there were, people would complain that your off topic comment was off topic from the last off topic comment. OY!
>>> 5. Why not just post topics that are off topic with a heading that starts OT - then everyone knows what they are and can read or ignore as they prefer? <<<
What is "on topic" and what "off topic"? To one person AF is now off topic because Mark has introduced DWM. To another AF is on topic because the topic is Mark's Time Management systems. To another Covey is on topic because the topic is really Time Management systems in general. To others goals and values are on topic because in order to be effective in doing anything you need those, or so goes one school of thought. We've had discussions on planning, intuition, and what kinds of book to write in or software program to use. What the HELL is really ON topic? ;-)
>>> 6. I believe that in any forum we have to respect each other and each others views. There is nothing wrong with having a bit of fun or a bit of a ramble into other areas, but how about doing it on specific OT threads and please everyone? <<<
Amen to the idea of respect. But I hope I have demonstrated the futility of even deciding what is relevant to whom. If Mark had more of a dictatorial bent, he would lay down a law. That is just not Mark, however so we have a lot of latitude ... and it has worked for the year and a quarter or so I've been here ... and other have been here longer and seem to be thriving.
Reply by Norman U.
Mike:
"iv)"
You are learning.
I had an FF extension count the number of instances of my name in your tome. Pretty good. But let's try to do better next time. I might actually read it.
"iv)"
You are learning.
I had an FF extension count the number of instances of my name in your tome. Pretty good. But let's try to do better next time. I might actually read it.
Reply by Mike
Allison,
As I seem not to be tired of flogging this horse ;-)
>>> <>
I for one don't find it so easy to sort the wheat from the chaff. One has to scan every post to find out if it is on topic or not - a bit of a waste of time on a time management forum. <<<
Honestly, I can't think of a post that as taken me a full minute to read. Many take a lot longer to analyze and respond to, but those are clearly of interest to me.
>>> Why is it so hard to exercise a little self discipline and keep off topic comments in an off topic thread or threads? <<<
I'll bet that if you posted an answer to someone which was more than 100 words or so, I could pick it apart and show you how it was off topic, by some contrived idea of what would be on topic for the question asked. (Not that I'm the kind of person who would DO such a despicable thing ;-)
>>> <>
So why are you here if it's so easy and time management is no problem for you? <<<
I don't read that in Norm's response at all. How does being willing to scan through verbosity imply a mastery of time management skills? I can't make that connection.
>>> It may be that there are a number of readers who have been here for ages and know mostly what they want to know about the various systems on offer - but what about new people? It's very disconcerting to post a question then have to soft through a load of totally unrealted text to find the solution to something that may be of importance to that person. <<<
But is that not always the case? First of all, the person who asked the question does not know what is related ... if he did, he most likely would not have had the question in the first place. Secondly, if he DOES know what is related, he is probably wrong and will find out when he reads ideas he might never have thought of. Finally, maybe he will learn something interesting about the phases of the moon that he never knew and even though it was not what he was looking for, be greatly amused. So why do you feel that you should arbitrate, or even COULD arbitrate this kind of thing?
>>> I respect the fact that you have been here for a while Norman, and that you probably have learnt all you want to regarding time management, but not everyone is in this enviable position. <<<
And that is why there are here to drink from the depths of the fountain of Norman's wisdom. ;-) Seriously, though, people come here for advice AND GET IT. Your complaint might have merit if all we did was point fingers, giggle, and dance around at every question. But we ANSWER, with vigor, and humor, and good will ... and if the answer is not understood, we answer AGAIN, and AGAIN ... and at no cost at all, except to ask for a little tolerance and understanding in return.
>>> I also worry that Mark may just decide to pull the plug on the whole forum with all this bickering. I very much doubt that he needs all this hassle. <<<
Why would he? And what hassle is Mark experiencing? He does not have to scold the children very often. The most of his work comes from cleaning out the SPAM. I don't know, but I get the sense that Mark can scan through text very quickly ... he's a writer, after all. I know posts here are not exactly advanced calculus! ;-)
Honestly, I believe that what you see is a mature forum, with multiple ideas each with its own adherents and so there will be different answers to many questions then ensuing discussion about why the answers differ. Basically, Mark has produced five successful time management systems and opened up the floor to discussion ... that's the price of success.
As I seem not to be tired of flogging this horse ;-)
>>> <>
I for one don't find it so easy to sort the wheat from the chaff. One has to scan every post to find out if it is on topic or not - a bit of a waste of time on a time management forum. <<<
Honestly, I can't think of a post that as taken me a full minute to read. Many take a lot longer to analyze and respond to, but those are clearly of interest to me.
>>> Why is it so hard to exercise a little self discipline and keep off topic comments in an off topic thread or threads? <<<
I'll bet that if you posted an answer to someone which was more than 100 words or so, I could pick it apart and show you how it was off topic, by some contrived idea of what would be on topic for the question asked. (Not that I'm the kind of person who would DO such a despicable thing ;-)
>>> <
So why are you here if it's so easy and time management is no problem for you? <<<
I don't read that in Norm's response at all. How does being willing to scan through verbosity imply a mastery of time management skills? I can't make that connection.
>>> It may be that there are a number of readers who have been here for ages and know mostly what they want to know about the various systems on offer - but what about new people? It's very disconcerting to post a question then have to soft through a load of totally unrealted text to find the solution to something that may be of importance to that person. <<<
But is that not always the case? First of all, the person who asked the question does not know what is related ... if he did, he most likely would not have had the question in the first place. Secondly, if he DOES know what is related, he is probably wrong and will find out when he reads ideas he might never have thought of. Finally, maybe he will learn something interesting about the phases of the moon that he never knew and even though it was not what he was looking for, be greatly amused. So why do you feel that you should arbitrate, or even COULD arbitrate this kind of thing?
>>> I respect the fact that you have been here for a while Norman, and that you probably have learnt all you want to regarding time management, but not everyone is in this enviable position. <<<
And that is why there are here to drink from the depths of the fountain of Norman's wisdom. ;-) Seriously, though, people come here for advice AND GET IT. Your complaint might have merit if all we did was point fingers, giggle, and dance around at every question. But we ANSWER, with vigor, and humor, and good will ... and if the answer is not understood, we answer AGAIN, and AGAIN ... and at no cost at all, except to ask for a little tolerance and understanding in return.
>>> I also worry that Mark may just decide to pull the plug on the whole forum with all this bickering. I very much doubt that he needs all this hassle. <<<
Why would he? And what hassle is Mark experiencing? He does not have to scold the children very often. The most of his work comes from cleaning out the SPAM. I don't know, but I get the sense that Mark can scan through text very quickly ... he's a writer, after all. I know posts here are not exactly advanced calculus! ;-)
Honestly, I believe that what you see is a mature forum, with multiple ideas each with its own adherents and so there will be different answers to many questions then ensuing discussion about why the answers differ. Basically, Mark has produced five successful time management systems and opened up the floor to discussion ... that's the price of success.
Reply by Mike
Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman Norman
'zat better? LOL ;-)
More to the point, and a deeply philosophical question, is this post ON topic or OFF?
Hmmm
'zat better? LOL ;-)
More to the point, and a deeply philosophical question, is this post ON topic or OFF?
Hmmm
Reply by Norman U.
An example of a thread that due to its nature stays "on topic":
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1053326
Interesting question. No immediate clear answer. Thoughtful replies and questions.
See also all those idiosyncratic implementations of AF / DWM on electronic devices: specific subject, few but very interested participants, specific problems with concrete answers.
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1053326
Interesting question. No immediate clear answer. Thoughtful replies and questions.
See also all those idiosyncratic implementations of AF / DWM on electronic devices: specific subject, few but very interested participants, specific problems with concrete answers.
Reply by Alison R
Well, it seems to me that this forum is very different from others I am used to. Obviously it has evolved this way - my comments were really in response to this thread and the fact that I had noticed a shift in the way the forum seemed to be used.
I will continue to come here to glean what I can find useful and of interest. And rest assured that I in no way have thought to suggest anyone should leave. My response to Normans comment was based on my interpretation of what he said - I felt he implied something different to what he obviously thought, and my 'why are you still here' comment was a genuine question based on this.
I will continue to come here to glean what I can find useful and of interest. And rest assured that I in no way have thought to suggest anyone should leave. My response to Normans comment was based on my interpretation of what he said - I felt he implied something different to what he obviously thought, and my 'why are you still here' comment was a genuine question based on this.
Reply by Alison R
<
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1053326
Interesting question. No immediate clear answer. Thoughtful replies and questions.
See also all those idiosyncratic implementations of AF / DWM on electronic devices: specific subject, few but very interested participants, specific problems with concrete answers.>>
Yes I agree this is a great example of a thread which had stayed on topic.
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1053326
Interesting question. No immediate clear answer. Thoughtful replies and questions.
See also all those idiosyncratic implementations of AF / DWM on electronic devices: specific subject, few but very interested participants, specific problems with concrete answers.>>
Yes I agree this is a great example of a thread which had stayed on topic.
Reply by Mike
Norman,
Yeah, but even there Gerry suggested that a closed list might not always be useful (a digression from it it WAS a closed list) and Serpahim went into motivational considerations and even commented on Gerry's alternative TM system. So it all depends on how you define the "topic". I'm not criticizing or evaluating the on topicness of that thread ... just noting that by SOME standard it did go off topic. And that is just fine. It is perhaps more coherent than most. But do we really want to go in and delete Gerry's and Seraphim's post because they strayed? That would be a loss.
Yeah, but even there Gerry suggested that a closed list might not always be useful (a digression from it it WAS a closed list) and Serpahim went into motivational considerations and even commented on Gerry's alternative TM system. So it all depends on how you define the "topic". I'm not criticizing or evaluating the on topicness of that thread ... just noting that by SOME standard it did go off topic. And that is just fine. It is perhaps more coherent than most. But do we really want to go in and delete Gerry's and Seraphim's post because they strayed? That would be a loss.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Mike "other(s) have been here longer and seem to be thriving". You are forgetting David whose plight I suspect started this thread. David had been here for several years before he took offense to perceived and actual personal attacks. Avrum too.
Norman: you're off topic ;-)
Norman: you're off topic ;-)
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Ack this thread is going too quickly. The above post is in response to stuff written on the previous page =-(
Reply by Mike
Alan,
David quit a number of times, that is just David. Avrum was pretty clear, I thought, that he had learned what he needed and found continued new systems to be distracting. A number of people have reverted and some have left while others remain.
David quit a number of times, that is just David. Avrum was pretty clear, I thought, that he had learned what he needed and found continued new systems to be distracting. A number of people have reverted and some have left while others remain.
Reply by Jacqueline
Maybe part of the problem that's not really a problem is that we (society) associates time management with work - and heaven forbid if work is any fun or enjoyable. Maybe that's part of the attraction for people to this particular forum - it self-selects people who don't know how to do some things with anything but sweat and stress.
Norman, thank you very much for providing me with some learning opportunities about myself in the last while that I haven't really been paying attention to apart from the last day or so. I'll try not to hit the snooze button in future. Oh, and I hope your friend is ok.
Norman, thank you very much for providing me with some learning opportunities about myself in the last while that I haven't really been paying attention to apart from the last day or so. I'll try not to hit the snooze button in future. Oh, and I hope your friend is ok.
Reply by Steve
Pretty soon this forum is gonna be "All-Norman All-the-Time" which might be interesting, who can say? And who are we to judge? It's astonishing that this prospect is so daunting to people. I, for one, am willing to stick around and see the result. Even if it turns out to be a trainwreck, there's still an aesthetic appeal in that. It's also interesting to see how much time is being wasted (on a time-management message board, no less) on such nonsense. I don't exclude myself either -- far from it. Or maybe that point is obvious. Again, who can say?
Reply by Rainer
Steve,
though I can see the aesthetic appeal in waisting discretionary time, it is the waist of discretionary mental energy that causes me to refrain from participating in this experiment.
though I can see the aesthetic appeal in waisting discretionary time, it is the waist of discretionary mental energy that causes me to refrain from participating in this experiment.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
This forum has been AWESOME to me for 6 months now. I've never encountered another forum of similar value, though I do have personal relations that offer such value in areas other than self-time-management.
It will continue to be awesome if people keep contributing. A secular radio program I heard this morning talked about how complaints wear us down. Instead of complaining, dwell more on the good things of life, and refrain from negativity. Ask "how can I make things better", not "how can I stop others making things worse". In this forum, that means contribute questions and answers.
You can't coerce change. Try the sunny side of life instead. :-)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyYZUhSeRYc
It will continue to be awesome if people keep contributing. A secular radio program I heard this morning talked about how complaints wear us down. Instead of complaining, dwell more on the good things of life, and refrain from negativity. Ask "how can I make things better", not "how can I stop others making things worse". In this forum, that means contribute questions and answers.
You can't coerce change. Try the sunny side of life instead. :-)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyYZUhSeRYc
Reply by Damien
A way to avoid "All-Norman All-the-Time" is to ask contributors to keep it to a maximum of 5 post a day. This way we get, a more interesting, socratic dialogue when people decide to use different names to keep it all in the limits :)
Post length is sometimes a problem for me as I am a slow reader- scroller, if Andreas could automate this too I would be happy.
Post length is sometimes a problem for me as I am a slow reader- scroller, if Andreas could automate this too I would be happy.
Reply by Mike
>>> A way to avoid "All-Norman All-the-Time" is to ask contributors to keep it to a maximum of 5 post a day. <<<
Yes, what a great idea. And only 15 words in length. And only if typed on an MS Windows computer. And preferably an Acer model. Oh, and no use of the "N" key. LOL ;-) ;-)
>>> This way we get, a more interesting, socratic dialogue when people decide to use different names to keep it all in the limits :) <<<
I don't know why that would force a Socratic approach. But as to different names... I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked to think that such a thing would go on, right here, in River City! LOL ;-)
>>> Post length is sometimes a problem for me as I am a slow reader- scroller, if Andreas could automate this too I would be happy. <<
LOL ;-) Seriously, try scanning at high speed then guess what the post was about. You'll get good at it with practice.
Yes, what a great idea. And only 15 words in length. And only if typed on an MS Windows computer. And preferably an Acer model. Oh, and no use of the "N" key. LOL ;-) ;-)
>>> This way we get, a more interesting, socratic dialogue when people decide to use different names to keep it all in the limits :) <<<
I don't know why that would force a Socratic approach. But as to different names... I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked to think that such a thing would go on, right here, in River City! LOL ;-)
>>> Post length is sometimes a problem for me as I am a slow reader- scroller, if Andreas could automate this too I would be happy. <<
LOL ;-) Seriously, try scanning at high speed then guess what the post was about. You'll get good at it with practice.
Reply by Mel
Mike & Norman,
Thanks again for the levity break! This is my only post of the day, but I'm afraid it will be more than 15 words, Mike. I'm so very sorry. lol Does this shut me down for the month? lol
It seems to me that if the primary purpose of this forum weren't community, Mark could just post an FAQ page and be done with it. That may be useful for newbies anyway. Do those of you who dislike the OT posts and humor have any idea how many deserted forums there are? We could run an experiment and see what would happen to this one if all the regulars quit posting for a while. I certainly know my prediction! I had quit visiting the forum regularly until the interpersonal stuff got interesting. I enjoy answering questions, but how many of them are there? And by the time I get here, they've typically been answered by several posters. Sure, I'm interested in on-topic stuff, too, but there's so very little to be had here these days. That's why I asked before for people to post topically and if they can't, I don't think there should be complaints about OT posts. If you can't find the information you're looking for amidst a post with many replies, repost it! There are several here who will gleefully give you the info as often as you need it.
I've belonged to groups that rigidly enforced OT rules and those that did not. I never belonged to the OT-enforced ones for long. I can Google for answers. I participate in groups for community.
Thanks again for the levity break! This is my only post of the day, but I'm afraid it will be more than 15 words, Mike. I'm so very sorry. lol Does this shut me down for the month? lol
It seems to me that if the primary purpose of this forum weren't community, Mark could just post an FAQ page and be done with it. That may be useful for newbies anyway. Do those of you who dislike the OT posts and humor have any idea how many deserted forums there are? We could run an experiment and see what would happen to this one if all the regulars quit posting for a while. I certainly know my prediction! I had quit visiting the forum regularly until the interpersonal stuff got interesting. I enjoy answering questions, but how many of them are there? And by the time I get here, they've typically been answered by several posters. Sure, I'm interested in on-topic stuff, too, but there's so very little to be had here these days. That's why I asked before for people to post topically and if they can't, I don't think there should be complaints about OT posts. If you can't find the information you're looking for amidst a post with many replies, repost it! There are several here who will gleefully give you the info as often as you need it.
I've belonged to groups that rigidly enforced OT rules and those that did not. I never belonged to the OT-enforced ones for long. I can Google for answers. I participate in groups for community.
Reply by TK
I've been a part of several OT-enforced boards and all have been pretty successful. One way to do it is to not create a separate forum, but a mechanism when posting that allows you to select whether the post is OT or not. Then when you view the board, you have a choice of viewing all threats or only OT threads. I would guess though that in order for that to be worth it in terms of time for Mark or a board mod, we'd need a lot more traffic through here.
Norman U makes a good point about this probably not being a problem, but I disagree with the primary purpose behind the forum that Mel describes. Likely part of the reason that Mark did not just toss up a FAQ was to stem the tide of questions that come his way-that's where the forum comes in. I don't think that requires a community at all and certainly not some of the OT stuff that goes on here, but just a group of people that are familiar with Mark's writings.
Ultimately people will vote with their feet or mousepads. Obviously Mark is trying to drive business by setting up this site and once the site stops doing that this forum is doomed to hit the rubbish bin.
Norman U makes a good point about this probably not being a problem, but I disagree with the primary purpose behind the forum that Mel describes. Likely part of the reason that Mark did not just toss up a FAQ was to stem the tide of questions that come his way-that's where the forum comes in. I don't think that requires a community at all and certainly not some of the OT stuff that goes on here, but just a group of people that are familiar with Mark's writings.
Ultimately people will vote with their feet or mousepads. Obviously Mark is trying to drive business by setting up this site and once the site stops doing that this forum is doomed to hit the rubbish bin.
Reply by Will
We have tried various wikis in the past, and ChristineB did a very helpful AF1 FAQ linking in posts on a number of recurring themes. However, we found that the ongoing conversation suited us best.
If anyone feels like using their newfound google site:... skills to pull together another FAQ for DWM, I'm sure no-one would object.
If anyone feels like using their newfound google site:... skills to pull together another FAQ for DWM, I'm sure no-one would object.
Reply by Dave L.
Thinking this through, if someone posts an on-topic comment in a off-topic thread, is that grounds for censure ? :-)))
Reply by Steve
When posting on the message board, simply insert the three-letter abbreviation (ONT) after any sentence you deem to be "On-topic" (ex. ONT). When there is an off-topic sentence, you simply insert the corresponding abbreviation (OFT for "Off-Topic Sentence") at the end (ONT). Sometimes I wonder if Norman and Mark aren't the same person (OFT). When navigating through a topic, you can use the "Search / Replace" function to guide you from one "ONT-sentence" to the end of the next "Ont-Sentence." (ONT) Then simply backspace to the beginning of that sentence and read it -- with full confidence that you are "on-topic." (ONT) I've never seen Norman and Mark in the same room together (OFT) . Using these simple abbreviations should make the message board much easier to navigate and should remove any need for policing (ONT).
Reply by acedia
Drawing a distinction between 'on' and 'off' topic posts would be like dividing your list (AF or DWM) into sections. We don't do that here! Anything can be added to the end of the list, be it 'build a deck' or 'take over the world' (TM Mike) There's no need to decide first where these belong, just add them to the list and see if it stands out . . . So why not treat the forum the same way?
When the task 'check Mark's forum' stands our, I turn on my timer and check the forum. If a post - new or old - stands out, I read it. While reading it, I assess if it is too irritating / boring / irrelevant to my needs and stop reading, if so. Sometimes while reading a post, I get a strong desire to go clean the oven! When the timer rings, I stop reading and go back to my list.
@ Will: I hope someone has the time to take up your suggestion - not me at the moment unfortunately - and BTW I still really miss ChristineB! I hope she is well and making great use of her time!
When the task 'check Mark's forum' stands our, I turn on my timer and check the forum. If a post - new or old - stands out, I read it. While reading it, I assess if it is too irritating / boring / irrelevant to my needs and stop reading, if so. Sometimes while reading a post, I get a strong desire to go clean the oven! When the timer rings, I stop reading and go back to my list.
@ Will: I hope someone has the time to take up your suggestion - not me at the moment unfortunately - and BTW I still really miss ChristineB! I hope she is well and making great use of her time!
Reply by acedia
. . . and speaking of people I miss, where is vickie aka 'learning as i go" ?? I haven't seen a post from her in ages. I hope she too is well and making great use of her time!
Is anyone here in touch with either ChristineB or vickie?
Is anyone here in touch with either ChristineB or vickie?
Reply by Norman U.
Dave L:
"Thinking this through, if someone posts an on-topic comment in a off-topic thread, is that grounds for censure ? :-)))"
If you would like a rigorous discussion of such matters, I advise reading the extension of Goedel first incompleteness theorem to any symbolic system robust enough to refer to itself.
In light of discussion of axiomatic systems:
Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )
"Thinking this through, if someone posts an on-topic comment in a off-topic thread, is that grounds for censure ? :-)))"
If you would like a rigorous discussion of such matters, I advise reading the extension of Goedel first incompleteness theorem to any symbolic system robust enough to refer to itself.
In light of discussion of axiomatic systems:
Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )
Reply by Norman U.
Steve,
Really? Tell me this irony, please.
As if smileys were not bad enough.
Really? Tell me this irony, please.
As if smileys were not bad enough.
Reply by vegheadjones
Norman:
In no way is this statement a priori true: Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )
Yet the following two statements are:
A statement is witty if it is witty
A statement is insightful if it is insightful
Therefore: A statement is witty and insightful if it is witty and insightful. The addition of an emoticon has nothing to do with whether a statement has these qualities or not.
In no way is this statement a priori true: Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )
Yet the following two statements are:
A statement is witty if it is witty
A statement is insightful if it is insightful
Therefore: A statement is witty and insightful if it is witty and insightful. The addition of an emoticon has nothing to do with whether a statement has these qualities or not.
Reply by Norman U.
Since folks seem to be engaging in matters of taxonomy:
When the most lively thread on a board is about the board itself which claims to be primarily devoted to time management, especially the systems as developed by Mark Forster, what exactly is the the board about?
As noted above those who want to develop all kindsa systems to regulate what they think are off-topic discussion would place that energy into developing on-topic content, their complaints would disappear.
But Mel's posts, Standing's posts, Mike's posts, etc. have pretty much explained the culture of most boards / newsgroups.
These discussions develop on all boards. What confounds me is that the volume of posts here is relatively low, so there is really no need to have much division. And as noted above the discussion flows organically.
It is not as if anyone is coming here to discuss the Obama health care package (thank God), but it might be mentioned in a few posts apropos to the topic at hand. But I have yet to see any topic dominate a thread that had nothing to do with the thread or personal relationships of the folks participating.
Face it, most posts (save when Mark first introduces a new systems), are pretty much exhausted as such rather quickly. The sorta threads I mentioned above being the exception.
When the most lively thread on a board is about the board itself which claims to be primarily devoted to time management, especially the systems as developed by Mark Forster, what exactly is the the board about?
As noted above those who want to develop all kindsa systems to regulate what they think are off-topic discussion would place that energy into developing on-topic content, their complaints would disappear.
But Mel's posts, Standing's posts, Mike's posts, etc. have pretty much explained the culture of most boards / newsgroups.
These discussions develop on all boards. What confounds me is that the volume of posts here is relatively low, so there is really no need to have much division. And as noted above the discussion flows organically.
It is not as if anyone is coming here to discuss the Obama health care package (thank God), but it might be mentioned in a few posts apropos to the topic at hand. But I have yet to see any topic dominate a thread that had nothing to do with the thread or personal relationships of the folks participating.
Face it, most posts (save when Mark first introduces a new systems), are pretty much exhausted as such rather quickly. The sorta threads I mentioned above being the exception.
Reply by Norman U.
Jacqueline,
Thanks for asking. He is stable, but not outta the woods (whatever that means). Secondary complications, specifically pneumonia. He's OK in the sense of what this means, but his family are having a harder time.
Btw, this is off-topic.
I could discuss how AF helps in this situation but perhaps this an example best for the discussion with Alan.
Thanks for asking. He is stable, but not outta the woods (whatever that means). Secondary complications, specifically pneumonia. He's OK in the sense of what this means, but his family are having a harder time.
Btw, this is off-topic.
I could discuss how AF helps in this situation but perhaps this an example best for the discussion with Alan.
Reply by Seraphim
If you want to discuss Obamacare, you can join Mike's spinoff group specifically intended for the more in-depth off-topic stuff. :-) http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Philosophical_Ideas/
Reply by Mike
Just a few quick comments covering all the various ideas here ;-)
I've not heard from Christine, I too hope she is well. Perhaps someone can prevail on Mark to contact her back channel again?
Vickie is fine and working her projects and walking Missy ... last time I heard prancing about in a pretty pink raincoat (Missy, not Vickie ;-)
Re: The suggestions for tagging each line. I think that is great. We could prevail on Andreas (who is probably much too sane to even respond) to produce a text analyzer to scan all posts and show us just what we what to read. Then there would be no need at all to expose ourselves to the risk of coming across any new ideas.
Sure, if you want to engage in off-topic chatter, my list is as good a place as any. But beware, there is no way to post anything really off-topic because there is nothing defined to be ON topic. So long as you understand the risk involved.
I've not heard from Christine, I too hope she is well. Perhaps someone can prevail on Mark to contact her back channel again?
Vickie is fine and working her projects and walking Missy ... last time I heard prancing about in a pretty pink raincoat (Missy, not Vickie ;-)
Re: The suggestions for tagging each line. I think that is great. We could prevail on Andreas (who is probably much too sane to even respond) to produce a text analyzer to scan all posts and show us just what we what to read. Then there would be no need at all to expose ourselves to the risk of coming across any new ideas.
Sure, if you want to engage in off-topic chatter, my list is as good a place as any. But beware, there is no way to post anything really off-topic because there is nothing defined to be ON topic. So long as you understand the risk involved.
Reply by Norman U.
Andreas already wrote the only script you need: one which removes all content save mine.
Your welcome.
Your welcome.
Reply by learning as I go
OFT (no smiley)
Hi acedia and mike
Thanks for the shout out.....all's well here! I hope things are well with you!
learning as I go
Hi acedia and mike
Thanks for the shout out.....all's well here! I hope things are well with you!
learning as I go
Reply by Alan Baljeu
She's back! Missed you around here, learning. Hope you'll tarry a bit.
Reply by Steve
I, too, am delighted that "learning as I go" is back (OFT). This conversation has long been in need of her great humor and good-sense (ONT). However, I hope that "learning as I go" does not mind if I correct her use of the (ONT) and (OFT) symbols (ONT).
In her latest post, "learning as I go" uses the OFT symbol at the BEGINNING of a sentence (ONT). This was most confusing and caused me to spend needless seconds back-spacing in search of the Off Topic sentence when in fact the sentence was right there in front of me (ONT). On a time-management message board, such a misuse of time is extremely regrettable (ONT). Therefore, I humbly beseech "learning as I go" to place the (ONT) and (OFT) symbols in their correct position when using them in the future (ONT).
In her latest post, "learning as I go" uses the OFT symbol at the BEGINNING of a sentence (ONT). This was most confusing and caused me to spend needless seconds back-spacing in search of the Off Topic sentence when in fact the sentence was right there in front of me (ONT). On a time-management message board, such a misuse of time is extremely regrettable (ONT). Therefore, I humbly beseech "learning as I go" to place the (ONT) and (OFT) symbols in their correct position when using them in the future (ONT).
Reply by Mike
As Steve vies with Norman for the crown in the Great Irony Contest, the rest of us look on, helplessly and in confusion as our Irony Meters lie, broken, in ruins, at our feet, the pieces strewn around us. ;-(
Reply by Rainer
Mike,
no confusion here, the result is clear.
The mistake the ENTP (Norman) made was to try to challenge the irony and sarcasms of the INTJ (Steve) at all. No way.
It would be the same as if I would engage in one of the threads dominated by Norman: I would be bored to death by his constantly changing flow of ideas, visions, concepts, etc. No chance to communicate for me there.
Maybe it's a matter of self-protection, or a matter of dealing with our pains, wounds, and fears, I don't know.
Let's face it, folks:
all people are equal, but none of them are the same.
Let's just agree that we disagree.
no confusion here, the result is clear.
The mistake the ENTP (Norman) made was to try to challenge the irony and sarcasms of the INTJ (Steve) at all. No way.
It would be the same as if I would engage in one of the threads dominated by Norman: I would be bored to death by his constantly changing flow of ideas, visions, concepts, etc. No chance to communicate for me there.
Maybe it's a matter of self-protection, or a matter of dealing with our pains, wounds, and fears, I don't know.
Let's face it, folks:
all people are equal, but none of them are the same.
Let's just agree that we disagree.
Reply by Mike
As I was reading your post I was sure that you were about to say:
All people are equal, but INTP/5s are more equal than the others.
Of course, since Norman chews glass, who wants to mess with HIM? ;-)
All people are equal, but INTP/5s are more equal than the others.
Of course, since Norman chews glass, who wants to mess with HIM? ;-)
Reply by Rainer
LOLROTF! :-)
Reply by Will
I think I follow Norman's train of thought on smileys. They appear to mimic two unpleasant meatspace behaviours:
- laughing at your own jokes (just boorish) and
- saying something provocative and then retreating behind a claim that of course you weren't serious (mealy-mouthed cowardice).
On the other hand, in a meatspace conversation you are permitted to smile.
Aren't you?
:o(
- laughing at your own jokes (just boorish) and
- saying something provocative and then retreating behind a claim that of course you weren't serious (mealy-mouthed cowardice).
On the other hand, in a meatspace conversation you are permitted to smile.
Aren't you?
:o(
Reply by Alan Baljeu
It is extremely hard to discern whether someone is happy, angry, joking, or whatever by reading text. I've seen flame wars erupt over the failure to be clear in this matter. Writing ;-) isn't laughing at your jokes, it's simply indicating the previous was meant as a joke. On the other hand this is boorish laughing at a joke: "So the Indian said, 'scrambled!' lololololol rotflmao lolololol!!1!1!"
Reply by Will
Quite so. If we were all:
a) literary geniuses AND
b) coming from the same culture
it would be nice to think that our writing would be good enough. But this is a democratic and diverse medium.
I must admit to a guilty temptation to use ;-) when I don't have confidence in what I have written but don't have the time or energy to tidy it up. ;-)
a) literary geniuses AND
b) coming from the same culture
it would be nice to think that our writing would be good enough. But this is a democratic and diverse medium.
I must admit to a guilty temptation to use ;-) when I don't have confidence in what I have written but don't have the time or energy to tidy it up. ;-)
Reply by Dave L.
Norman:
"If you would like a rigorous discussion of such matters ...."
Thanks just the same but I'll take a pass on that offer.
"Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )"
I'm still processing your ending that statement with a smiley - perhaps Goedel addresses this.
I appreciate everyone's discussions and insights here on AF/DIT/DWM questions that come up - IMHO you're a helpful group. Not to worry if conversation wanders at times - it's natural. And I feel as others have pointed out that the occasional use of emoticons (as opposed to my nervous "burst" earlier) helps bridge the gap of not seeing the actual facial expression of the poster.
"If you would like a rigorous discussion of such matters ...."
Thanks just the same but I'll take a pass on that offer.
"Smileys always diminish the wit or insight of the statement made ; )"
I'm still processing your ending that statement with a smiley - perhaps Goedel addresses this.
I appreciate everyone's discussions and insights here on AF/DIT/DWM questions that come up - IMHO you're a helpful group. Not to worry if conversation wanders at times - it's natural. And I feel as others have pointed out that the occasional use of emoticons (as opposed to my nervous "burst" earlier) helps bridge the gap of not seeing the actual facial expression of the poster.
Reply by Mark Forster
Long ago in the last century when the internet first started we used to express shades of emotion or facial expression like this: (often abbreviated ) or or .
I haven't seen anyone do that in years .
Reply by Norman U.
Mark:
"Long ago in the last century when the internet first started we used to express shades of emotion or facial expression like this: (often abbreviated ) or or .
I haven't seen anyone do that in years "
The emotional markup language. This I found less contemptible especially the tag. Using the HTML based tags themselves where in a sense ironic, especially when first used by a small community who knew their origin. Strange loops: irony to connote irony.
Smileys just seem to undercut too harshly language.
They are killing people's sense of irony and humor (in the contemporary and original sense of the word). And I don't buy the "written word" is difficult to discern argument. That is the point. We have become lazy readers. Imagine Bierce or Wilde or Twain or Nietzsche or Johnson or Voltaire or Augustine using such nonsense.
Smileys are also making their way into common oral communication as well. Folks just can't let a joke, a jab, a bite of sarcasm, a touch of irony just linger without immediately killing it with a "just joking" or literally saying "jk".
"Long ago in the last century when the internet first started we used to express shades of emotion or facial expression like this:
The emotional markup language. This I found less contemptible especially the tag. Using the HTML based tags themselves where in a sense ironic, especially when first used by a small community who knew their origin. Strange loops: irony to connote irony.
Smileys just seem to undercut too harshly language.
They are killing people's sense of irony and humor (in the contemporary and original sense of the word). And I don't buy the "written word" is difficult to discern argument. That is the point. We have become lazy readers. Imagine Bierce or Wilde or Twain or Nietzsche or Johnson or Voltaire or Augustine using such nonsense.
Smileys are also making their way into common oral communication as well. Folks just can't let a joke, a jab, a bite of sarcasm, a touch of irony just linger without immediately killing it with a "just joking" or literally saying "jk".
Reply by Will
"" - really? After all these happy months? We'll miss it!
I think is subtly different from :o), though I can't put my finger on exactly how.
I think
Reply by Norman U.
Will,
"" - really? After all these happy months? We'll miss it!
An end tag closes simply one element not the entire class of them. Unfortunately, for many here.
"" - really? After all these happy months? We'll miss it!
An end tag closes simply one element not the entire class of them. Unfortunately, for many here.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Well, IMO Nietsche would be sooo much easier to understand if he had just inserted a few appropriately placed emoticons....
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Incidentally for a long time I believed Norman was truly an egomaniac based on the content of his posts. It took a lot of posts before that perception adjusted. (And no, I'm not interested in assigning any labels to Norman nor deconstructing him or his writings.) Perhaps the difficulty of understanding on the internet (besides not taking the time) is the lack of volume. A body of work provides a context to interpret a passage more accurately. Lacking such a body, the passage ought to take pains to explain itself more clearly.
Reply by Dave L.
Norman:
"And I don't buy the "written word" is difficult to discern argument. That is the point. We have become lazy readers."
Sad but true, especially among the younger generations (no offense meant to anyone here, just my opinion based on my grandchildren and others I know). When you read a book, you get a sense of the author's style and to me that's no small part of the enjoyment I get from reading.
However, the written word in a forum discussion comes in much smaller packets. Unless you're reading the entire thread at one sitting it's easy to miss the style of each person posting, especially for someone newer who isn't acquainted with all the players and their (forum) writing style. (Or maybe it's my own reading laziness coming to the surface.)
But in general, I agree with Norman on this. The 'digital generations' in society today are conditioned to have very short attention spans and little if any discipline or delayed gratification. Kudos to any parent or other person who influences our young people counter to this trend. I'm working on my crew, but it's an uphill battle. If there is to be an Armageddon, I can well imagine it starting when all the batteries in the world's handheld devices go dead at the same time.
BTW, Norman - your post didn't pass the syntax check - there is no opening tag.
"And I don't buy the "written word" is difficult to discern argument. That is the point. We have become lazy readers."
Sad but true, especially among the younger generations (no offense meant to anyone here, just my opinion based on my grandchildren and others I know). When you read a book, you get a sense of the author's style and to me that's no small part of the enjoyment I get from reading.
However, the written word in a forum discussion comes in much smaller packets. Unless you're reading the entire thread at one sitting it's easy to miss the style of each person posting, especially for someone newer who isn't acquainted with all the players and their (forum) writing style. (Or maybe it's my own reading laziness coming to the surface.)
But in general, I agree with Norman on this. The 'digital generations' in society today are conditioned to have very short attention spans and little if any discipline or delayed gratification. Kudos to any parent or other person who influences our young people counter to this trend. I'm working on my crew, but it's an uphill battle. If there is to be an Armageddon, I can well imagine it starting when all the batteries in the world's handheld devices go dead at the same time.
BTW, Norman - your post didn't pass the syntax check - there is no opening
Reply by Dave L.
Alan - I was posting while you were posting apparently.
Reply by Norman U.
David L:
"However, the written word in a forum discussion comes in much smaller packets. Unless you're reading the entire thread at one sitting it's easy to miss the style of each person posting, especially for someone newer who isn't acquainted with all the players and their (forum) writing style. (Or maybe it's my own reading laziness coming to the surface.)"
My solutions from the slings and arrows of online discourse for decade(s).
The easy and quick method:
Don't take yourself or others too serious.
The more difficult and rewarding method:
A hermeneutics of charity. You didn't get to know Proust in one sentence either. You take each one as they come. Same here or in face to face discourse. Why not adopt a stance of charitable curiosity (a redundancy in their root meanings). Of course a hermeneutics of charity does not mean simply letting a text go on and on without criticizing it or ignoring its difficult and frustrating parts and challenging them. As Augustine pointed out so long ago, it is exactly those tough spots which require most of our attention and charity. We have to willing to keep re-reading in light of that next sentence. We really have no other choice. How we attempt to read, we do have some choice in. What goes for texts goes for relationships. When it gets difficult is when something interesting might occur, but that takes effort.
A hermeneutics of suspicion always is thoroughly circumscribed by charity. Suspicion alone is the way of the sophist and the scoffer and the person who would not be surprised.
If you are careful, you might be surprised how that next sentence radically alters all those which came before.
When it comes to the behavior or actions of others, we can never know if they are following the dictate of Augustine: Love God, and then what you will, do it. It is funny that for the most part Kierkegaard in all his brilliance is often just commentary on this line.
"However, the written word in a forum discussion comes in much smaller packets. Unless you're reading the entire thread at one sitting it's easy to miss the style of each person posting, especially for someone newer who isn't acquainted with all the players and their (forum) writing style. (Or maybe it's my own reading laziness coming to the surface.)"
My solutions from the slings and arrows of online discourse for decade(s).
The easy and quick method:
Don't take yourself or others too serious.
The more difficult and rewarding method:
A hermeneutics of charity. You didn't get to know Proust in one sentence either. You take each one as they come. Same here or in face to face discourse. Why not adopt a stance of charitable curiosity (a redundancy in their root meanings). Of course a hermeneutics of charity does not mean simply letting a text go on and on without criticizing it or ignoring its difficult and frustrating parts and challenging them. As Augustine pointed out so long ago, it is exactly those tough spots which require most of our attention and charity. We have to willing to keep re-reading in light of that next sentence. We really have no other choice. How we attempt to read, we do have some choice in. What goes for texts goes for relationships. When it gets difficult is when something interesting might occur, but that takes effort.
A hermeneutics of suspicion always is thoroughly circumscribed by charity. Suspicion alone is the way of the sophist and the scoffer and the person who would not be surprised.
If you are careful, you might be surprised how that next sentence radically alters all those which came before.
When it comes to the behavior or actions of others, we can never know if they are following the dictate of Augustine: Love God, and then what you will, do it. It is funny that for the most part Kierkegaard in all his brilliance is often just commentary on this line.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
"A hermeneutics of charity." Bingo!
"If you are careful, you might be surprised how that next sentence radically alters all those which came before." Which is why I always read your posts twice.
"If you are careful, you might be surprised how that next sentence radically alters all those which came before." Which is why I always read your posts twice.
Reply by Rainer
"A hermeneutics of charity."
What does that mean? Does this relate to the book of Smith and Venema?
What does that mean? Does this relate to the book of Smith and Venema?
Reply by Rainer
Btw, "Ben-Gurion" is even stronger than "Ultimo".
Reply by Norman U.
Ranier:
Might want to google hermeneutics and look at the wiki.
In short for now: it was an approach developed to read texts, specifically the Bible in the Christian tradition. Certainly hermeneutics had been used prior (but not really developed explicitly), but with Augustine begins the explicit discussion of how one approaches a text, again specifically the Christian Scriptures.
Augustine believed (in short) that in order to understand a text (again the Christian scriptures) two primary precepts, stands, modes of being, etc. had to be understood or taken up:
Love of God.
Love of one's fellow man.
Implied in his writing is also love of the writings themselves. In light or within the horizon of such love, only then can only fully engage in interpretation of Scripture, especially the difficult parts, which many would like to pass over or quickly explain away. (Jesus calling people dogs.) For Augustine, these "dark passages" is where understanding and relation with the text, God, and one's fellow man truly begins.
Hermeneutics over time became more and more explicitly developed especially in the 18th and 19th centuries expanding the method to texts outside the Christian Scriptures. Hermeneutics as such began to be looked at and attempted to be understood in a hermeneutic manner.
In the 20th century, a radical shift was made in hermeneutics. Heidegger applied this understanding to understanding of everyday life. To "man" how related to the world.
This insight would shake philosophy and all the social science, especially on the Continent and in the Anglo-American world (except in Philosophy.)
A so-called hermeneutics of suspicion has been described beginning in the late 19th century and early 20th century. It often suggested as a departure of a hermeneutics of charity. In other words, rather than love being the fundamental relationship of one to a text or another person or the world, the understanding of that relationship should be first put under suspicion.
The great triad of hermeneuts (practioners of hermeneutics as such) of suspicion are commonly held to be: Nietzsche, Freud, and Marx.
This is an extreme misunderstanding, for these men first and foremost loved those texts they looked at and those people they attempted to understand and the world around them. It might be hard to see at first, but within a hermeneutics of charity it is clear these men were lovers of what they wished to understand.
In fact, I doubt that any struggle to understand anything cannot be marked primarily by love, even if that love is not made explicit.
The basic tenet of hermeneutics (we are talking in the most simple of terms) is that when you approach a text, a person, or the world, you already have an understanding of it. That understanding might something like: "this is a book" or just "this is something." Nevertheless within that understanding you already bringing a lot to the table and as you read or relate further to that which you are trying to understand, that further understanding informs your prior understanding, And that new insight to your first encounter informs the next. Thus the hermeneutic circle.
This is most easily seen in texts. You read the first sentence of Proust. You have some idea what to expect before even beginning to read him. Each sentence informs your initial understanding and every prior sentence which then serves to inform your understanding of the current sentence and the next.
Thus understanding has a circular or spiraling nature. It is not one of a tabula rasa where you just learn new stuff. Or a tinker toy analogy where you just are adding knowledge piece by piece in some network of understanding governed by rules which can be made explicit (cognitive science).
This might all seem basic, but there is plenty of nuance to it. Especially when it comes to understanding everyday life.
Something like the word "prejudice" becomes a vice in our era, but without a pre-judgement no matter how clear that pre-judgement is to us, is necessary to understand anything. So pre-judgement is not a "bad" thing or barrier to understanding, but rather the very condition of understanding. As we engage what our pre-judgement has allowed us to understand in some manner, hermeneutics can then help us understand those latent pre-judgements and how they help or hinder of our understanding. But alway keeping in mind that these pre-judgements can never be made fully explicit, for no knowledge can ever be made completely explicit.
This is not bad news, but the good. For a good interpreter is always ready to be surprised, to be wrong, because he necessarily is wrong in the sense he can never understand something completely. The fullness of understanding can never be had. This allows a certain distance between the interpreter and the interpreted. With the right balance, with love, a reciprocal relationship can develop and respect be developed.
For if we are primarily understanding beings, what are we without that which we attempt to understand? To fully understand something, would be self-destruction and destruction of the understood, whether a text or another person or the world. To engage in the hubris of believing on can fully understand or a rejection of our own relation to world as understanding entities is too impoverish ourselves and the world around us.
In short.
Might want to google hermeneutics and look at the wiki.
In short for now: it was an approach developed to read texts, specifically the Bible in the Christian tradition. Certainly hermeneutics had been used prior (but not really developed explicitly), but with Augustine begins the explicit discussion of how one approaches a text, again specifically the Christian Scriptures.
Augustine believed (in short) that in order to understand a text (again the Christian scriptures) two primary precepts, stands, modes of being, etc. had to be understood or taken up:
Love of God.
Love of one's fellow man.
Implied in his writing is also love of the writings themselves. In light or within the horizon of such love, only then can only fully engage in interpretation of Scripture, especially the difficult parts, which many would like to pass over or quickly explain away. (Jesus calling people dogs.) For Augustine, these "dark passages" is where understanding and relation with the text, God, and one's fellow man truly begins.
Hermeneutics over time became more and more explicitly developed especially in the 18th and 19th centuries expanding the method to texts outside the Christian Scriptures. Hermeneutics as such began to be looked at and attempted to be understood in a hermeneutic manner.
In the 20th century, a radical shift was made in hermeneutics. Heidegger applied this understanding to understanding of everyday life. To "man" how related to the world.
This insight would shake philosophy and all the social science, especially on the Continent and in the Anglo-American world (except in Philosophy.)
A so-called hermeneutics of suspicion has been described beginning in the late 19th century and early 20th century. It often suggested as a departure of a hermeneutics of charity. In other words, rather than love being the fundamental relationship of one to a text or another person or the world, the understanding of that relationship should be first put under suspicion.
The great triad of hermeneuts (practioners of hermeneutics as such) of suspicion are commonly held to be: Nietzsche, Freud, and Marx.
This is an extreme misunderstanding, for these men first and foremost loved those texts they looked at and those people they attempted to understand and the world around them. It might be hard to see at first, but within a hermeneutics of charity it is clear these men were lovers of what they wished to understand.
In fact, I doubt that any struggle to understand anything cannot be marked primarily by love, even if that love is not made explicit.
The basic tenet of hermeneutics (we are talking in the most simple of terms) is that when you approach a text, a person, or the world, you already have an understanding of it. That understanding might something like: "this is a book" or just "this is something." Nevertheless within that understanding you already bringing a lot to the table and as you read or relate further to that which you are trying to understand, that further understanding informs your prior understanding, And that new insight to your first encounter informs the next. Thus the hermeneutic circle.
This is most easily seen in texts. You read the first sentence of Proust. You have some idea what to expect before even beginning to read him. Each sentence informs your initial understanding and every prior sentence which then serves to inform your understanding of the current sentence and the next.
Thus understanding has a circular or spiraling nature. It is not one of a tabula rasa where you just learn new stuff. Or a tinker toy analogy where you just are adding knowledge piece by piece in some network of understanding governed by rules which can be made explicit (cognitive science).
This might all seem basic, but there is plenty of nuance to it. Especially when it comes to understanding everyday life.
Something like the word "prejudice" becomes a vice in our era, but without a pre-judgement no matter how clear that pre-judgement is to us, is necessary to understand anything. So pre-judgement is not a "bad" thing or barrier to understanding, but rather the very condition of understanding. As we engage what our pre-judgement has allowed us to understand in some manner, hermeneutics can then help us understand those latent pre-judgements and how they help or hinder of our understanding. But alway keeping in mind that these pre-judgements can never be made fully explicit, for no knowledge can ever be made completely explicit.
This is not bad news, but the good. For a good interpreter is always ready to be surprised, to be wrong, because he necessarily is wrong in the sense he can never understand something completely. The fullness of understanding can never be had. This allows a certain distance between the interpreter and the interpreted. With the right balance, with love, a reciprocal relationship can develop and respect be developed.
For if we are primarily understanding beings, what are we without that which we attempt to understand? To fully understand something, would be self-destruction and destruction of the understood, whether a text or another person or the world. To engage in the hubris of believing on can fully understand or a rejection of our own relation to world as understanding entities is too impoverish ourselves and the world around us.
In short.
Reply by Mark Forster
Norman U:
<< The emotional markup language. >>
We didn't call it that then. There was no association with html tags that I was aware of. In fact html wasn't even available for emails when I started. I never saw the / sign used.
As you say these markers could be creative in themselves, and added something to the message.
<< The emotional markup language. >>
We didn't call it that then. There was no association with html tags that I was aware of. In fact html wasn't even available for emails when I started. I never saw the / sign used.
As you say these markers could be creative in themselves, and added something to the message.